This microforum brought to you
by the principle of
TRANSPARENCY

Forum 410 • Proletarism proposal comments
Proletarism proposal


older
posts
more
recent
posts
-- page 203 --
Click the vote button to vote for posts that you consider informed or thoughtful. Posts with the most votes will be put on the best page.
IMPORTANT: You can vote for as many different comments as you want, but please,
DON'T try to stack the vote by voting multiple times for the same comment.

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Interesting ... I will think about this
• • Thursday • 19-Aug-2010 • 10:12 am • # 410-2200

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Interesting ... I will think about this
• TOR • Monday • 16-Aug-2010 • 6:44 pm • # 410-2199
New Name
I think your point about needing a new name is an interesting one that really does need to be considered and taken very seriously, especially after the problems we encountered in the 20th century and people's long memory of those problems. However, I think that proletarism is just too odd for a name and really doesn't cut it, as the very term from which it is derived, proletariat, is itself too obscure to begin with and should not be a term from which we derive the name of a new political tendency. While the term 'workerist' does have negative connotations in the movement, as it is a word used to critique those that either eschew political work outside the workplace or simply focus mainly on workplace-based organizing without having a broader political face, I don't think the average person even knows about these connotations, and would still really like the term as a word to describe what it is we stand for and want to build, which is a workers' society rather than a bourgeois one. After all, what we are trying to build is workers' rule, and most workers don't use the term 'proletariat' and would probably see it as belonging in the 19th century, which is the same way they see the word bourgeoisie.
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Interesting ... I will think about this
• Red 39 • Monday • 14-Jun-2010 • 12:30 pm • # 410-2198
A New Dawn
Trotskyism, Maoism, Stalinism, etc. all speak of serious past mistakes. We may refer to them for reference but a new beginning requires fresh thought. The "Proletarist Movement" works.
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Other
• ADOLF • Thursday • 4-Mar-2010 • 10:51 am • # 410-2197
no
You guys are all crazy and need to be locked up. Seek help immediately. Or refer to a history textbook for numerous examples of how your doctrine has failed spectacularly in the past.
• Question: Have you consulted a psychiatrist?
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• Cory • Thursday • 7-Jan-2010 • 11:22 pm • # 410-2196
Thankyou
I recently went to a CPUSA meeting in Los Angeles. I was basically forced out because they were nothing but democrats posing as Communists and I believe whole heartidly in a working class revolution. I spoke my mind and scared them all. I need desperately to connect with people that believe as I do.
• Question: How can I get in contact?
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Not sure ... I may (or may not) think about this
• • Friday • 20-Nov-2009 • 10:55 am • # 410-2194

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• • Monday • 16-Nov-2009 • 12:30 pm • # 410-2193

good comment
comment • • Wednesday • 11-Nov-2009 • 9:27 am • # 410-2192

What are main and major classes under marxism
• Question: What are main and mainor classes under marxism
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should place our faith in third-world dictators
• hobbes • Sunday • 8-Nov-2009 • 3:12 pm • # 410-2191
I love imperialist pigs!!!!
dude, dictators are the ---bleep--- man. i love people telling me what to do everyday. see, I am indecisive, and having someone telling me how to eat, drink, and ---bleep--- is wonderful.
good comment
comment • Constantine • Wednesday • 16-Sep-2009 • 11:36 am • # 410-2190

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• Gavin • Sunday • 12-Jul-2009 • 12:23 pm • # 410-2189
Bless the motherland.
Bless the motherland for all its worth,
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing "Communism"
• • Sunday • 5-Jul-2009 • 5:00 pm • # 410-2188

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing "Communism"
• • Saturday • 4-Jul-2009 • 5:04 pm • # 410-2187

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Interesting ... I will think about this
• Ásgeir • Tuesday • 16-Jun-2009 • 9:36 am • # 410-2186
good read
Never thought that the soviet union represented a purely communist state but it also showed many flaws regarding the ruling system of communism. Too much centralization only results in squalor and the production wont be able to supply the needs of the citizen efficiently enough
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Interesting ... I will think about this
• Axel • Friday • 22-May-2009 • 8:07 pm • # 410-2185

I believe in using the name Communism, but I also believe that currently it's a loaded title that frightens people. If renaming it, hopefully only temporarily, brings people to the movement, it should be considered.
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing "Communism"
• • Thursday • 7-May-2009 • 4:36 am • # 410-2184

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• Sjn • Sunday • 26-Apr-2009 • 10:24 am • # 410-2183
Good Idea
Communism and even Neo-Marxism, scares people
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing "Communism"
• • Monday • 16-Mar-2009 • 3:20 pm • # 410-2182

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing "Communism"
• • Tuesday • 10-Mar-2009 • 6:43 pm • # 410-2181

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We can gradually reform away the abuses of capitalism
• • Sunday • 22-Feb-2009 • 8:41 pm • # 410-2180

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• alex • Friday • 13-Feb-2009 • 11:49 pm • # 410-2179
workers of the world unite!
i really liked this peice, it really sums up well how i feel and really does a good job on the bourgeois argument of "the soviet union killed people, so there for capitalism is right"
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• alex • Thursday • 12-Feb-2009 • 11:34 pm • # 410-2178
workers of the world unite!
i really liked this peice, it really sums up well how i feel and really does a good job on the bourgeois argument of "the soviet union killed people, so there for capitalism is right"
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• • Thursday • 22-Jan-2009 • 7:36 am • # 410-2177

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• Paul • Monday • 19-Jan-2009 • 3:39 pm • # 410-2176
Another name
I agree that we do need to separate ourselves from Stalinistic forms of Communism. Also Communism has gained a bad name from people who have used it to suppress its peoples. I also believe Proletist Movement is too bland and most people don't know what a proletariat is. World Workers Party would be good in my opinion.
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing "Communism"
• • Monday • 29-Dec-2008 • 9:56 am • # 410-2175

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Interesting ... I will think about this
• edge • Thursday • 27-Nov-2008 • 2:31 am • # 410-2174
The corruption of communist leaders
The name communism has been stained by the aturicties commmited in its name, thus hindering its propectics of gathering large scale support. "Communist" states should be pne to critque by the people, their failures examined and re-addreesed. Through a model in which if an elected individual fails to serve the proletriat they are immediatly removed from office.
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing "Communism"
• Zeke • Sunday • 2-Nov-2008 • 11:08 am • # 410-2173

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• Maurice • Saturday • 1-Nov-2008 • 6:43 pm • # 410-2172
lgexjf
http://betahistine.zenavo.cn http://plan-b-7.zuvexry.cn http://zenavo.cn http://mestinon-133.zostura.cn http://panoxyl-848.zostura.cn http://antibiotic-2.zenavo.cn http://nebilet-563.zostura.cn http://health-119.zipace.cn http://virility-patch-rx.zyreloj.cn http://solution-8.zyreloj.cn http://health-93.zipace.cn http://treatment-10.zyreloj.cn http://keppra.zostura.cn http://multiple-sclerosis-1-190.zostura.cn http://nursing-25.zostura.cn http://flextra.zipace.cn http://stress-12-451.zuvexry.cn http://solution-20-444.zyreloj.cn http://health-93.zipace.cn
• Question: lgexjf
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing "Communism"
• Vlad • Wednesday • 22-Oct-2008 • 8:37 pm • # 410-2171
The division of "Communist" leaders
Logicaly, to every group there is a good side and a bad side. In the group of "Communist" leaders there is a major separation between the power hungry Stalinists to the great Vladimir Lenin. I would agree with the Proletarist statement if the "treachery" phrase was removed.
• Question: Why is murder bad? When you eat almost anything it could be considered murder.
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We can gradually reform away the abuses of capitalism
• • Thursday • 16-Oct-2008 • 8:38 am • # 410-2170

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing Trotskyism
• • Wednesday • 1-Oct-2008 • 12:06 am • # 410-2169

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Interesting ... I will think about this
• altsin • Sunday • 14-Sep-2008 • 6:31 pm • # 410-2168

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing Anarchism
• • Friday • 5-Sep-2008 • 5:00 am • # 410-2167

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should place our faith in third-world dictators
• • Monday • 25-Aug-2008 • 1:14 pm • # 410-2166

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Other
• Fen • Monday • 11-Aug-2008 • 9:24 pm • # 410-2165
rofl
Communism will never work. Get a real job, scrubs.
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Interesting ... I will think about this
• mike • Monday • 4-Aug-2008 • 5:11 pm • # 410-2164
lol
theres the grenade wheres the pin there it is... run!!!
• Question: Is that comment completely stupid?
good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• Argentino • Tuesday • 22-Jul-2008 • 5:07 pm • # 410-2163

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• • Thursday • 29-May-2008 • 4:06 am • # 410-2162

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing "Communism"
• Edvard Kardelj • Sunday • 4-May-2008 • 12:07 pm • # 410-2161
Communism will prevail
Comrades, let us not forget who fought and won in the 2nd world war. Let us not disgrace the memory of our fallen comrades who died so we can live in freedom. LONG LIVE COMMUNISM! LONG LIVE TITO!
good comment
comment • Torkelton • Thursday • 10-Apr-2008 • 9:40 pm • # 410-2160

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• • Thursday • 20-Mar-2008 • 11:47 pm • # 410-2159

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should place our faith in third-world dictators
• • Saturday • 12-Jan-2008 • 1:07 am • # 410-2158

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing Anarchism
• • Friday • 14-Dec-2007 • 1:12 am • # 410-2157

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• Robbie • Tuesday • 30-Oct-2007 • 1:31 am • # 410-2156

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Interesting ... I will think about this
• • Friday • 5-Oct-2007 • 12:28 pm • # 410-2155

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We should stick to existing Anarchism
• • Monday • 24-Sep-2007 • 8:33 pm • # 410-2154

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• • Thursday • 20-Sep-2007 • 3:43 pm • # 410-2153

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • No! -- We can gradually reform away the abuses of capitalism
• • Wednesday • 19-Sep-2007 • 11:24 pm • # 410-2152

good comment
comment
poll response:
••• What do you think of the proposal to name
the revolutionary workers' movement
the Proletarist movement? • Yes! -- This helps to make clear a decisive break with the treachery of "communist" leaders
• • Wednesday • 19-Sep-2007 • 2:28 pm • # 410-2151


older
posts
more
recent
posts
-- page 203 --
Click the vote button to vote for posts that you consider informed or thoughtful. Posts with the most votes will be put on the best page.
IMPORTANT: You can vote for as many different comments as you want, but please,
DON'T try to stack the vote by voting multiple times for the same comment.

This microforum has been brought to you
by the principle of
TRANSPARENCY

Interactivity for this site
by the Red Team


Information refineries
for the proletarian century